What all these elements have in common is the fact of perverting Islam and having little to do with its original message. The problem is aggravated by irrational fatalism. In other words, humankind has gone in the wrong direction and followed the road to perdition. The main means is jihad , which can be either violent or peaceful. When the diagnosis is this sombre, one expects the number of enemies to multiply. When one believes oneself to be in the right, one expects the various forms of error to coalesce against oneself.
The clandestine apparatus comprises various levels and its members have different ranks that correspond to degrees of initiation. You do not join the Brothers: they co-opt you after they have surrounded you, helped you, observed you and tested you.
When the diagnosis is this black, it has to be kept alive, fed and confirmed. But they also have no hesitation in resorting to far less commendable techniques such as lying, mythicizing and totally inventing. Some of my colleagues have contested this diagnosis, arguing that systematic lying is not an exclusive prerogative of the Brothers.
It should therefore be added that these lies render communication with other political forces difficult because they create a parallel imagination, a form of surrealism that stigmatizes the other and a memory that has almost nothing in common with the other collective imaginations and is opposed to them. This counter-society will have its own memory: a mishmash of real and invented facts that tell a holy story punctuated by trials which are sufferings sent by God and victories. What is the nature of the relationship with Muslims who do not belong to the Brotherhood?
But they are also the uninitiated who do not know the truth about perdition. Or they are victims. Everything depends on the situation, the religious and political map of the country under consideration and the people involved. The movement mistrusts intellectuals and debates. Training a hundred men was more valuable than writing a book. Furthermore, the main defections — the ones that have done the most harm — are the defections of intellectuals and educated people. This statement must be relativized, however.
Inside the Muslim Brotherhood - The Truth About The Worlds Most Powerful Political Movement
In this, he was like many other Islamist intellectuals, who took their first steps within other groups. The argument is crystal clear: God has denied men the right to make laws, reserving to Himself this prerogative, and the fact of not recognizing this and appropriating this right amounts to apostasy. No great musician, poet or writer has been a Brother. There is the professor of philosophy or the jurist operating at a decent or above-average level but the most brilliant Islamist intellectuals are not Brothers.
The Brothers produce professors, teachers, doctors and engineers. In some countries, they have almost succeeded in killing the film industry by putting pressure on actors and actresses, whilst some of their executives have fought and often obtained the banning of this or that thinker e. Some are liberal, others are conservative and still others are very rigid.
On the other hand, the organization is a clandestine, secret apparatus that is rigidly hierarchical and ruled with a rod of iron or is presumed to be because these parties with a Leninist structure are often Brezhnevian. Indeed, keeping the political environment in mind, the Qutbists have often wanted a person acceptable to the authorities or the public to occupy the highest post.
There are no candidacies to become a Brother: one is co-opted. They help them, surround them, do sports with them, involve them in group activities and gradually structure their social universe; unless they decide that the candidate is not a good recruit. At this point, the neo-Brother is introduced into a cell called an usra, which is led by a militant who has access to the next level. There are various degrees of belonging: between three and five, according to different authors. This contradiction can be smoothed away by arguing that the lowest levels are not really part of the organization but are still a trial period.
The organization is overseen by the Shura Council and a Guidance Office. Once a decision had been taken, however, everyone had to fall into line with it. Others are opposed to those who prefer preaching to politics and vice versa. It should be noted that the latter do not dare to reject his works openly and try to convince themselves that he was saying something other than what he was really saying.
- Inside the Muslim Brotherhood - The Truth About The World's Most Powerful Political Movement.
- Kuhusu mwandishi.
- Conservation and Sustainable Development: Linking Practice and Policy in Eastern Africa (Earthscan Conservation and Development);
- What happened to Egypt's Muslim Brotherhood?.
One of these the Sudanese branch has come to power. Some have allied themselves to regimes, others have opposed them and all change their position according to the circumstances. On the whole, t he strategy is intended to be gradualist , which fact does not rule out recourse to violence. The project was seriously compromised by divisions following the invasion of Kuwait, however.
- Minchinhampton and Amberley Through Time.
- Accessibility links;
- The Shooting Star.
Many branches of the Brotherhood put their money on the Iraqi president Saddam Hussein, and the other branches never forgave them for this. They all know each other and consult each other but the general rule is that every branch decides its own line of action. When there are disputes, the two conflicting parties can jointly request arbitration from the centre where the Egyptians are over-represented. It should be noted that the Egyptian motherhouse is usually far more rigid and dogmatic than the other branches.
Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read. Want to Read saving…. Want to Read Currently Reading Read. Other editions. Enlarge cover. Error rating book. Refresh and try again.
See a Problem?
Open Preview See a Problem? Details if other :. Thanks for telling us about the problem. Return to Book Page. Douglas Thompson. Get A Copy. Hardcover , pages. More Details Edition Language. Friend Reviews. To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up. Lists with This Book. This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Community Reviews. Showing Rating details.
More filters. Sort order. Aug 01, Akhlaq rated it liked it. That is that they were extremists who supported terrorists and worth stopping. That was perpetuated by Hosni Mubarak, who now is sitting in a cushy jail cell somewhere in Egypt and the very group he and the previous Presidential incumbents tried so hard to suppress, are now in power. The US, realising they have no option but to communicate effectively with the MB to make sure their ally Israel will be avoided any discomfort by its neighbours, is the primary concern. Book highlights how Nasser, Sadat and Gaddafi were plain and simply dictators who used the uniform to assert control over the masses, the political process and foreign policy.
What happened to Egypt's Muslim Brotherhood? | Egypt | Al Jazeera
It meant suffocating the MB so they were unable to guide the people out of their malaise that had been effectively sucked into by the President. He mediated in whatever conflict he was asked of, yet was unrelentingly pursued and his professional life destroyed. Yet he struggled to clear his name and maintained his patience throughout. He gives a different perspective of Sharia which makes sense. Sharia should not been as law but as social guidance on how to live our lives. Rather than being rigid, it should fluid and allow people to use aspects which they need whilst discussing other aspects that they might not to use and finding a suitable alternative.
Book also highlights of fickle the UN Security Council Committee is on sanctioning individuals alleged to have terrorist links. The US or any other Western nation, it seems, are able to add any person without having to provide any proof. This system is open to severe exploitation that will see individuals like Nada, hunted down and have assets frozen; unable to get a credit card and no-one allowed to financially help, all on the basis of allegations than evidence.
Oct 16, Paul Sutliff rated it it was ok Shelves: islam. Book has good examples of taqqiya in it. It also shows shows provides names of North American members of the Ikhwan. Muhammad Hafiz rated it it was ok Oct 31, Rae Preston rated it really liked it Jun 17, Amru Khalid rated it liked it Oct 23,